Best Pizza in Downtown Buffalo

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Buffalo, NY at 665 Main St

Old World recipe. 1,000-degree hearth. Main Street, Buffalo.

Order online

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Hearth + Press

Hearth + Press brings an authentic Mediterranean experience together with local favorites in Buffalo. Our menu features ingredients imported from around the world, pizza baked in a 1000-degree Stone Hearth oven, and a family pizza dough recipe passed down through generations. Come dine with us and enjoy food rooted in family tradition and Old World inspiration.

The sausage pizza

Shredded mozz, sausage, and hot honey on a hand-stretched crust. One of the most-loved pies we make.

See the menu

The perfect match for every slice

Crafted to pair, built to refresh. Our bar serves up signature handcrafted cocktails, traditional spritzes, and classic favorites made with fresh ingredients—the perfect match for our 1,000° stone-hearth pizzas and authentic pasta dishes.

View full menu

Lightly creamy, hearty & filling

Savor our Chicken & Mushroom Penne: wood-fired chicken breast and roasted mushrooms tossed with hearty penne in a light cream sauce. It’s the perfect blend of light yet filling—crafted to bring rich Mediterranean comfort to every bite.

A Dining Experience Rooted in Tradition

At Hearth + Press, family tradition is part of the food we serve. Our pizza dough recipe has been passed down through generations, while ingredients are imported from around the world. Our 1000-degree Stone Hearth oven brings that tradition to the table, creating a dining experience that connects Old World inspiration with Buffalo favorites.

Dine With Us

From the kitchen

A family recipe, fired at 1,000 degrees

Our dough recipe came from the Old World and it hasn't changed. Watch our pizzaiolos craft each pie to order in the stone hearth oven.

Our story

Let us bring the flavor to your event

Creative menus, exceptional service. Our catering services are designed to make your event unforgettable.

Request catering

Your gathering, our place

We host private events for up to 150 guests. Birthdays, corporate dinners, rehearsal parties — bring your people and we'll handle the rest.

Explore private events

Guaranteed seating, effortless dining

Planning your visit? We recommend making an online reservation ahead of time to secure the best table in the house. Book today to guarantee your spot for fire-baked pizzas, handcrafted cocktails, and authentic Mediterranean pasta dishes.

Book a table

Find us in the Theatre District

📍 665 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203 📞 (716) 262-0866 🕒 Mon: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM Tue – Fri: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM Sat: 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM Sun: Closed

Get directions

Parking at Hearth + Press is easy

See our easy to use parking guide to find safe, close parking for the the best pizza restaurant in Buffalo.

Parking guide

This place in downtown Buffalo is a must go ASAP. You will love the food, staff, and overall vibe. Go see a show and start your night off there with an amazing dinner and fabulous beverages.

Anthony P.

Amazing amazing amazing, service food drinks everything is absolutely delicious. The bartender was kind and knowledgeable and our server helped make it our favorite place of the night! I highly recommend their espresso martini and spaghetti and meatballs. There’s no reason this place shouldn’t be on a wait on a Saturday night.

Bobby N.

We came from Atlanta and then walked 2.5 miles just to have this pizza. I had seen them on CBS mornings. They use flour from Italy which is what I use at home and doesn't bother my gluten intolerance. Worth every step!!!!!!

Tracey M.

I was looking for authentic Neapolitan style pizza and this place didn’t disappoint. If you are looking for a a great pizza come check them out.

Elmer B.